Off the Hook
Upscale Coastal / Farm-to-Table
Off the Hook brings fresh ingredients sourced from local farms & watermen, combining elevated coastal fare with creative cocktails.
Why go: Ideal for a date night or refined dinner with top-tier seafood and inventive cuisine.
Tip: Check their “Menu Changed Daily” board and arrive early for happy hour to maximize value.
View this post on Instagram
Sedona
American Fine Dining
Sedona has served Bethany Beach since 1993, delivering fresh local ingredients, craft cocktails, and house-made desserts.
Why go: For an intimate, upscale meal with excellent wine and dessert choices.
Tip: Reservations recommended; not the spot for kids or strollers.
View this post on Instagram
The Cottage Café
American / Casual Bistro
The Cottage Café has become a dining tradition in Bethany Beach—burgers, crab cakes, full entrees in a welcoming cottage-style setting.
Why go: A relaxed, reliable choice with broad appeal—great for families and casual dinners.
Tip: Go early for lunch or dinner to avoid the main rush.
View this post on Instagram
RopeWalk® Bethany Beach
Seafood / American / Waterfront
107 Garfield Parkway. Family-friendly, with a bay-front deck and a menu featuring fresh seafood, tacos, burgers and more.
Why go: A versatile pick for lunch or dinner with outdoor seating and scenic views.
Tip: Ask for deck seating and check happy hour specials at the bar.
View this post on Instagram
Bethany Blues Barbecue & Bourbon
BBQ / American Comfort
This spot fuses Southern-style barbecue with beach-town vibes, offering brisket, St. Louis ribs, crab cakes, and an extensive bourbon list.
Why go: For hearty comfort food, great cocktails and a lively atmosphere.
Tip: Their Sunday brunch is especially good; beers and bourbon pair well with the ribs.
View this post on Instagram
Bethany Boathouse
Casual / American / Family-Friendly
39817 Hickman Plaza Rd. An open-air restaurant with indoor/outdoor seating, live music, kids’ play area, and a broad menu for every mood.
Why go: A fun, relaxed choice when you’re with family or looking for a laid-back meal.
Tip: Check the events calendar for live music or DJ nights and plan ahead if you want outdoor seating.
View this post on Instagram
DiFebo’s Restaurant
Italian / Fine Dining
DiFebo’s serves handmade pastas, house-made breads and gourmet Italian dishes in a cozy, elevated setting.
Why go: For beautifully prepared Italian cuisine and a refined dining experience near the beach.
Tip: Go ahead with a dessert-course plan – their house breads and sweets are especially good.
View this post on Instagram
Bluecoast Seafood Grill & Raw Bar
Seafood / Raw Bar
Bluecoast serves fresh, simply-beautiful local seafood overlooking the scenic Salt Pond in Bethany Beach, with standout dishes like fried baby lobster tails and a robust raw bar.
Why go: For a refined seafood dinner with excellent wine and water views.
Tip: Sit on the deck for sunset views and arrive early for happy hour at the bar.
View this post on Instagram
Ocean 99
Coastal-Inspired / Seafood & American
99 Hollywood St. Ocean 99 offers a vibrant coastal-inspired menu featuring fresh seafood like seafood carbonara, shrimp & grits, creative cocktails and local craft beers—all in a relaxed yet upscale setting just steps from the beach.
Why go: A fresh, stylish pick for locals and visitors who want seafood with flair and good drinks.
Tip: Check their handcrafted cocktails and ask about the chef’s daily seafood specials—reservations recommended for peak times.
View this post on Instagram
Mango’s
Caribbean / American / Seafood
Mango’s offers a lively boardwalk setting with tropical-inspired dishes, ocean views, live music and a fun family-friendly vibe.
Why go: Good for a casual, energetic meal with beach views and island flair.
Tip: Choose a window or deck seat for the best view, and try their signature lobster tacos.
